Read Our Reviews         
Careers contact us today! 208-745-9406

Back to blog

Why Is My Tankless Water Heater Running Hot and Cold?

tankless water heater

There are a multitude of benefits to investing in a tankless water heater for your water heating needs rather than the traditional storage tank. For instance, tankless water heaters are more efficient than traditional models. This is because they are not subject to standby energy loss in the way that a tank model is.

Tank water heaters store a large amount of hot water, and when it’s not used promptly, the air surrounding the tank can cause it to cool off, wasting your energy. Tankless water heaters also take up far less room than their storage tank counterparts, and tend to last longer too. However, if you’re thinking of investing in a tankless water heater in Pocatello, ID, there are some important factors to keep in mind.

Problems With Tankless Water Heater Temperature

Tankless water heaters are not immune to problems. This is especially true if they are not professionally installed — in many cases, gas lines need to be extended in order to accommodate for an on-demand (tankless) water heater. In all cases, tankless water heaters must be property vented. If neither of these factors are properly addressed, then the tankless water heater might not be able to meet the demand being placed on it and will fail to work, as its computer system will be overloaded.

Another problem that tankless water heaters can run into is that of a cold water sandwich — a plumbing term given to sudden temperature fluctuations, when your tankless water heater produces hot and cold water intermittently.

These water temperature fluctuations can be caused by:

  1.  An improperly sized gas line, as mentioned above.
  2.  A plumbing system crossover where there shouldn’t be one.
  3.  Improperly lengthened venting pipes.
  4.  Damaged flow sensor — something that should be checked during your annual plumbing maintenance appointment.
  5.  A dirty water filter on the cold water inlet.
  6.  Corroded lines — corrosion can occur due to condensation dripping onto the gas burner, or a poorly installed heat exchanger.

Finally, another issue that homeowners often find with their tankless systems — if not properly installed and maintained — is mineral buildup. We’re talking about the accumulation of calcium and magnesium. This is otherwise known as hard water. Hard water can be and is a problem for pipes — creating hard scale within them that leads to clogs and/or corrosion.

A water softener will not only resolve this problem, but can improve your quality of life too, by making your showers and baths more refreshing, helping your drinking water taste better, and even helping your laundry last longer. If mineral buildup has already occurred in your tankless water heater’s lines, then you will need a professional to clean these lines before continuing to use your water heater system.

Fend Off Tankless Water Heater Problems With Maintenance

Be sure to schedule an annual plumbing maintenance appointment so that our professionally trained and highly experienced plumbers can fully assess your tankless water heater, water softener system, and the rest of your plumbing components. Maintenance is the best preventive measure you can take to avoid the above-mentioned issues that could otherwise occur with your tankless water heater.

If you’re experiencing your tankless water heater running hot then cold, or any other water heater issue, be sure to contact Advanced Home Services for top-rated plumbing services today!

craftsmanship guaranteed
water heater service


Request service


  • By submitting, you authorize Advanced Home Services to reach you via call, email, or text messages with offers and other information about your project’s needs. Message/data rates apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase.

maintenance program
Priority Service
High Performance
10% Discounts
No Emergency
Service Fees
What Our
Customers Are Saying

Noah was fantastic!!! He was very knowledgeable, courteous, and friendly. He kept us in the loop with diagnosing problems and the charges that would come along with it. He was incredible giving us options to best help us in our circumstances. We would highly recommend!


Amazing service! Everyone I worked with was knowledgeable and professional. Advanced home service always has our best interest in mind. We will continue to use their services for all of our home needs. Thank you all from the diagnosis team, salesman and installation crew. You guys are the best!


I have never encounter someone like Shawn H. He was here for hours at a very low price. Not only was he thorough he was so kind and very considerate. He did an amazing job keeping me informed and I would hire him again if needed... Shawn you are wonderfully amazing. Thank you so much for your time!


Called Advanced Home Services to schedule a routine furnace cleaning. Stewart did a great job and even tagged all our gas and water line so we would know which lines to shut off in case of an emergency. He was very friendly and helpful. I will be calling these guys for any future plumbing and heating issues that may pop up.


When Robert C came for a routine check found a leak under my kitchen sink. He discovered the main source of the problem and had the time to fix it right away before it became worse. He did a fantastic job and went above and beyond what was required. He was very friendly and so helpful and did a fantastic job.

proudly serving
southeast idaho
Rigby | Blackfoot |
Idaho Falls | Pocatello |
Rexburg | Shelley
& The Surrounding Cities